The Unfulfilled Promises of New Atheism

Did you find this article helpful? Share it!

In the early 2000s, New Atheism emerged with confidence and urgency. It argued that religion was not merely false, but socially harmful. If humanity could finally outgrow religious belief, they claimed, society would become more rational, peaceful and morally coherent.

Two decades later, it is worth asking a sober question: have the promises of New Atheism actually come true?

This article explores the core claims of New Atheism, examines the social outcomes we now observe, and considers why many of its hopes remain unfulfilled.

What New Atheism Promised

New Atheism was not simply disbelief in God. It was a programme for cultural reform.

Its central promises included:

A more rational public square free from superstition
Greater social harmony once religious conflict faded
A universal, secular moral framework grounded in reason
Intellectual honesty replacing dogma and tribalism

Religion, New Atheists argued, was the primary obstacle to human progress. Remove it, and society would naturally improve.

The Promise of Reason Over Dogma

One of New Atheism’s strongest appeals was its emphasis on reason, science and evidence. Belief without proof was portrayed as dangerous, even immoral.

Yet today, Western societies are not notably more rational or evidence-driven. Public discourse is increasingly emotional, polarised and hostile to nuance. Conspiracy theories flourish, trust in institutions has declined, and disagreement is often framed as moral failure rather than intellectual difference.

Ironically, the rejection of perceived religious dogma has not prevented the rise of new secular dogmas, many of which are equally resistant to debate.

The Promise of Social Unity

New Atheism suggested that without religion dividing humanity, people would find common ground more easily.

Instead, social fragmentation has intensified.

Political identity, ideology, culture and even personal lifestyle choices have become sources of deep division. In many cases, these divisions are enforced with a quasi-religious fervour, complete with heresies, excommunications and moral purity tests.

Religion did not disappear — but in some places it was replaced by competing belief systems that function religiously but lack the moderating traditions of established faiths.

The Promise of a Secular Moral Framework

New Atheists argued that morality does not require God. Ethics, they said, could be grounded in human wellbeing, evolutionary psychology or rational consensus.

In practice, this has proven difficult to sustain.

Without a shared transcendent reference point, moral agreement has fractured. Concepts such as justice, dignity and rights are frequently asserted, but their foundations are contested. Appeals to “harm” or “wellbeing” often collapse into subjective judgement, enforced by social pressure rather than moral reasoning.

The result is not moral clarity, or adherence to a moral law, but moral instability.

The Persistence of Meaning and Purpose

Perhaps the greatest unfulfilled promise of New Atheism concerns meaning.

Human beings do not merely seek explanations; they seek purpose, belonging and hope. New Atheism offered critique, but little in the way of existential replacement. Science can describe how the universe works, but it struggles to answer why life should matter.

As religious participation has declined in some places, rates of anxiety, loneliness and despair have risen. While correlation is not causation, the assumption that removing religion would leave people psychologically better off appears increasingly questionable.

Why These Promises Have Not Come True

The failure of New Atheism’s promises may stem from a flawed assumption: that religion is an irrational add-on to human nature rather than a deep expression of it.

Belief systems do not vanish when discredited; they are replaced. Ritual, moral narrative and ultimate meaning reassert themselves in new forms. The problem was never belief itself, but what we believe in.

By focusing almost exclusively on trying to dismantle religion, New Atheism underestimated the complexity of human moral and spiritual life.

Is This the End of New Atheism?

New Atheism’s cultural influence has waned significantly. Its leading figures are less central to public debate, and younger generations are less interested in the religion-versus-science conflict that once dominated headlines.

This does not signal a return to naïve faith, but it does suggest a growing recognition that pure negation is not enough. A society cannot be built on critique alone. We need God more than we realise.

FAQ: New Atheism, Belief in God, and Society

What is New Atheism?
New Atheism is a movement that gained prominence in the early 21st century, advocating outspoken criticism of religion and promoting secularism, science and rationalism.

Did New Atheism succeed in reducing religious belief?
In some Western countries, religious affiliation has declined. However, this trend predates New Atheism and has not produced the social outcomes its advocates predicted.

Has society become more rational without religion?
Despite increased scientific literacy, public discourse remains polarised and emotionally charged. Rational debate has not replaced belief-based thinking.

Can morality exist without God?
Some argue it can, but New Atheism has struggled to provide a widely accepted secular moral foundation that offers stability and consensus. As C. S Lewis observed, we have a Moral Law from a Moral Lawgiver encoded in us.

Is New Atheism still relevant today?
Its influence has diminished significantly, as cultural attention shifts toward questions of meaning, identity and belonging that New Atheism did not adequately address.

Is belief in God grounded in evidence?
Contrary to New Atheist claims, belief in God is not based solely on blind faith. Classical theism appeals to multiple forms of evidence, including philosophical arguments (such as contingency and fine-tuning), historical evidence, moral realism, and the intelligibility of the natural world.

Does science disprove God?
No. Science explains physical processes, but it does not address metaphysical questions such as why anything exists at all, why the universe is ordered, or why reason itself is reliable.

Is belief in God beneficial for society?
A substantial body of sociological research suggests religious belief is associated with stronger family stability, greater charitable giving, higher community cohesion and improved mental resilience.

Does religion cause more harm than good?
Both religious and secular ideologies have produced great good and great harm. The issue is not belief itself, but how belief is shaped, constrained and lived out.

Final Thoughts

New Atheism promised liberation — from superstition, conflict and moral confusion. What followed was not the clarity it envisioned, but a more fragmented and uncertain cultural landscape.

The lesson may not be that religion is beyond critique, but that human societies require more than disbelief to flourish. Reason matters, but so do meaning, tradition and shared moral vision.

If New Atheism taught us anything, it is that trying to remove old answers does not absolve us from the responsibility of finding better ones.

Thanks for Visiting!

If you enjoyed reading this post, and you think others might benefit from reading it, why not email it to a friend or share it on social media. Thank you!

Ready to Begin your Healing Journey?

If this has resonated with you and you feel you would benefit from discussing it in a therapeutic setting, contact us now in strict confidence. Don’t miss out on this opportunity! We are here to help.

My Book

You can also buy a copy of my book from Amazon

About me

Steven Lucas MBACP PNCPS (Accred) is a professional counselling psychotherapist working in Northamptonshire. Read Full Bio.

On a Personal Note:

This blog is more than words—it’s my way of creating a life of meaning, purpose, and support for the people I love most: my family.

After years of navigating life’s emotional highs and lows, I realised that what people crave isn’t just information—they want belonging, encouragement, and heart. That’s what I set out to share here.

Every post is crafted with intention: to inspire, to uplift, and to offer real hope. Whether you’re struggling with mental wellbeing, searching for personal growth, or simply looking to feel less alone in a busy world, you’re in the right place.

What drives me? The Lord and my family, and the belief that with empathy and authentic connection, we can build a better world—one reader at a time. Thanks for being here. You’re not just a visitor—you’re part of this journey.

Don’t Forget to Share your Thoughts in the Comments Section Below!

Healing isn’t linear, and emotional wellbeing isn’t a destination—it’s a relationship we build with ourselves over time. I’ve shared a piece of my journey here, but I know every path looks different. What’s helped you feel more grounded or whole lately? Whether it’s a small ritual, a big breakthrough, or even a question you’re still sitting with—I’d love to hear it. Your story might be exactly what someone else needs to read today.

Buy Me a Coffee?

If you’ve found comfort, insight, or encouragement here, and you’d like to say a little “thank you,” buying me a coffee is an amazing way to do just that. Your support helps me continue offering heartfelt content, maintaining a safe space for those seeking guidance, and expanding access to mental health support.

Whether it’s one coffee or a few, your gesture means the world. It tells me that what I’m doing matters—and that I’m not alone in this mission to bring light into people’s lives.

Disclaimer:

I am not a doctor so this guide should not be considered a replacement for seeking medical advice. It is also not a substitute for obtaining therapy as other factors, such as trauma, need to be considered.

There are pay per click ads on this site for which I may receive a small commission. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This helps to pay for the running of the site. I do not endorse any of the products advertised.

Some of the blog posts on this website include content that was generated or assisted by artificial intelligence (AI). While we strive for accuracy and clarity, AI-generated material may contain errors or reflect limitations in current technology. Please use your own judgment and consult professional sources when making decisions based on this content.